Licensed advisors in all 50 statesMon–Fri, 8am–8pm ET
Compare

Private PPO vs. COBRA Coverage

Keeping your exact plan at full freight, versus rebuying coverage on the open market.

A man carrying a box of belongings out of an office
The short version

Private PPO vs. COBRA Coverage

COBRA is not a plan. It is the right to keep the employer plan you already have — at the full premium, employer subsidy removed, plus an administrative fee.

That makes the comparison unusually clean: you already know exactly what COBRA covers, because you have been using it. The only real questions are what it costs you now and whether anything mid-treatment justifies that cost.

Side by side

COBRA vs. Private PPO

COBRA

  • Identical plan, identical network, identical deductible — nothing to relearn
  • Deductible and out-of-pocket amounts you already paid this year carry over
  • No underwriting and no gap in coverage
  • You pay the entire premium plus up to 2% admin — often three to five times your old payroll deduction
  • Generally limited to 18 months (longer in specific circumstances)
  • Election window is short, and retroactive election rules are easy to get wrong

Private PPO

  • Frequently a fraction of a COBRA premium for a healthy applicant
  • Available any day of the year, including the day your employer coverage ends
  • Broad nationwide PPO networks
  • Coverage runs on its own terms rather than expiring with an 18-month clock
  • Underwriting applies — a condition under active treatment can change the answer entirely
  • New plan year: your accumulated deductible resets to zero

Checkmarks mark the advantages of each option; open circles mark its trade-offs. Both columns list both.

What mattersCOBRAPrivate PPO
Typical costFull group premium + 2%Underwritten, often much lower
UnderwritingNoneYes
Keeps your current doctorsGuaranteedDepends on the network
Deductible already paidCarries overResets
How long it lastsUsually 18 monthsOngoing, per plan terms
Start dateRetroactive to coverage endFrom the effective date
Mid-treatment continuityUninterruptedNeeds careful review
Enrollment deadlineStrict election windowAny day
Questions worth asking

What to weigh before you choose.

Are you mid-treatment right now?

Surgery scheduled, a pregnancy in progress, active cancer treatment, an approved course of a specialty drug — in those cases COBRA usually wins even at an unpleasant price, because continuity of care and an already-satisfied deductible are worth real money.

This is the single most common reason an advisor will tell you not to switch.

How far into the plan year are you?

In November, a satisfied $4,000 deductible is worth more than two months of premium savings. In February it usually is not. The math genuinely flips depending on the calendar.

Do you have a Marketplace special enrollment period?

Losing employer coverage opens a 60-day Marketplace window, and if your income has dropped alongside the job, subsidies may now be in reach that were not before. Check that before comparing COBRA to anything private.

How long do you actually need coverage?

If a new job with benefits starts in six weeks, the question is which bridge is cheapest for six weeks. If you are self-employed now, you are choosing an ongoing plan, and COBRA's 18-month ceiling becomes a real constraint.

Best for COBRA

anyone mid-treatment, anyone late in a plan year with a large deductible already satisfied, and anyone who cannot risk a network change.

Best for a Private PPO

healthy people between jobs, anyone who has just gone self-employed, and anyone early in a plan year staring at a COBRA premium several times their old payroll deduction.

The plain-language verdict

COBRA buys continuity, and continuity is sometimes exactly what you are paying for. If nothing clinical is in flight and you are early in the plan year, an underwritten PPO usually costs dramatically less for comparable access. Check your special enrollment period either way.

General information only, not insurance, tax, or legal advice. Plan rules, availability and pricing vary by state, carrier and applicant. Verify Marketplace, Medicaid and COBRA details with the relevant official source before making a decision.

All comparisons

Next step

Have a licensed advisor apply this to your household.

Four questions. One call. If the alternative on this page is your better option, that is what you will be told.

  • One licensed advisor, not a lead pool
  • Enrollment open every day of the year
  • Pre-existing conditions covered
Free coverage review
Step 1 of 5

Let's find your coverage

Start with your state.

Secure & private. By submitting you agree to be contacted by one licensed advisor.

Find My Plans